Thought I'd share my SLAP with you all. Let me know what you think.
S: Is a greater total or average happiness of a society more important than the lowest common denominator of unhappiness of a society?
L: Waldron writes: “There is no right-based argument to be found which provides an adequate justification for a society in which some people have lots of property and many have next to none” (Waldron 5). He later writes: “Many of the most familiar arguments in favour of private property and against socialism are utilitarian arguments. They purport to show that the total or average happiness of society will be greater, or that the general welfare (under some other utilitarian conception) will be better served, if [a system of private property is used]” (Waldron 6).
A: It seems as though with the system of private property, yes, the total or average happiness of a society could be greater than with socialism, but it would be more polarized (the happy people would be very happy, and the unhappy people would be very unhappy). I think perhaps it would be more important to raise the lowest common denominator of unhappy people (this does not mean bringing everyone down to their level!) than to upkeep a high average happiness.
P: Would socialism ensure a less polarized level of happiness than a system of private property?
Monday, April 26, 2010
Saturday, April 24, 2010
Final Paper Thesis
Hey all, I'm tossing around two different theses for my final paper. I suppose the former would be more interesting, and harder to prove. The former would also be in contention with my midterm thesis (humans cannot rightfully be the owners of animals), since if under certain circumstances humans can own humans, it seems to follow that under certain circumstances humans can own animals.
The first:
Humans, under certain circumstances, can rightfully be the owners of other humans. By “rightful,” I mean that certain humans can sometimes have a morally valid claim to call certain other humans as under their ownership (I hesistate to use the word “property” here. Perhaps we need another word in reference to the ownership of humans). This is not an endorsement of slavery or oppression. This is problematic because some humans, when given ownership or power over another human, would abuse this power, possibly leading to slavery and oppression.
The second:
Humans cannot rightfully be the owners of other humans. By “rightful,” I mean that humans do not have a morally valid claim to call other humans their property. By “owners,” I mean humans who have the right to possess, control, sell, and decide the fate of other humans. This is in contention with the view that children are owned by their parents, and supplemented by the view that humans cannot rightfully be the owners of animals.
Thoughts/questions/concerns?
The first:
Humans, under certain circumstances, can rightfully be the owners of other humans. By “rightful,” I mean that certain humans can sometimes have a morally valid claim to call certain other humans as under their ownership (I hesistate to use the word “property” here. Perhaps we need another word in reference to the ownership of humans). This is not an endorsement of slavery or oppression. This is problematic because some humans, when given ownership or power over another human, would abuse this power, possibly leading to slavery and oppression.
The second:
Humans cannot rightfully be the owners of other humans. By “rightful,” I mean that humans do not have a morally valid claim to call other humans their property. By “owners,” I mean humans who have the right to possess, control, sell, and decide the fate of other humans. This is in contention with the view that children are owned by their parents, and supplemented by the view that humans cannot rightfully be the owners of animals.
Thoughts/questions/concerns?
Monday, April 12, 2010
Harrison Bergeron
For anyone who has not read it--
"Harrison Bergeron", by Kurt Vonnegut, Jr., 1961
THE YEAR WAS 2081, and everybody was finally equal. They weren't only equal before God and the law. They were equal every which way. Nobody was smarter than anybody else. Nobody was better looking than anybody else. Nobody was stronger or quicker than anybody else. All this equality was due to the 211th, 212th, and 213th Amendments to the Constitution, and to the unceasing vigilance of agents of the United States Handicapper General.
Some things about living still weren't quite right, though. April for instance, still drove people crazy by not being springtime. And it was in that clammy month that the H-G men took George and Hazel Bergeron's fourteen-year-old son, Harrison, away.
It was tragic, all right, but George and Hazel couldn't think about it very hard. Hazel had a perfectly average intelligence, which meant she couldn't think about anything except in short bursts. And George, while his intelligence was way above normal, had a little mental handicap radio in his ear. He was required by law to wear it at all times. It was tuned to a government transmitter. Every twenty seconds or so, the transmitter would send out some sharp noise to keep people like George from taking unfair advantage of their brains.
George and Hazel were watching television. There were tears on Hazel's cheeks, but she'd forgotten for the moment what they were about.
On the television screen were ballerinas.
A buzzer sounded in George's head. His thoughts fled in panic, like bandits from a burglar alarm.
"That was a real pretty dance, that dance they just did," said Hazel.
"Huh" said George.
"That dance-it was nice," said Hazel.
"Yup," said George. He tried to think a little about the ballerinas. They weren't really very good-no better than anybody else would have been, anyway. They were burdened with sashweights and bags of birdshot, and their faces were masked, so that no one, seeing a free and graceful gesture or a pretty face, would feel like something the cat drug in. George was toying with the vague notion that maybe dancers shouldn't be handicapped. But he didn't get very far with it before another noise in his ear radio scattered his thoughts.
George winced. So did two out of the eight ballerinas.
Hazel saw him wince. Having no mental handicap herself, she had to ask George what the latest sound had been.
"Sounded like somebody hitting a milk bottle with a ball peen hammer," said George.
"I'd think it would be real interesting, hearing all the different sounds," said Hazel a little envious. "All the things they think up."
"Um," said George.
"Only, if I was Handicapper General, you know what I would do?" said Hazel. Hazel, as a matter of fact, bore a strong resemblance to the Handicapper General, a woman named Diana Moon Glampers. "If I was Diana Moon Glampers," said Hazel, "I'd have chimes on Sunday-just chimes. Kind of in honor of religion."
"I could think, if it was just chimes," said George.
"Well-maybe make 'em real loud," said Hazel. "I think I'd make a good Handicapper General."
"Good as anybody else," said George.
"Who knows better then I do what normal is?" said Hazel.
"Right," said George. He began to think glimmeringly about his abnormal son who was now in jail, about Harrison, but a twenty-one-gun salute in his head stopped that.
"Boy!" said Hazel, "that was a doozy, wasn't it?"
It was such a doozy that George was white and trembling, and tears stood on the rims of his red eyes. Two of of the eight ballerinas had collapsed to the studio floor, were holding their temples.
"All of a sudden you look so tired," said Hazel. "Why don't you stretch out on the sofa, so's you can rest your handicap bag on the pillows, honeybunch." She was referring to the forty-seven pounds of birdshot in a canvas bag, which was padlocked around George's neck. "Go on and rest the bag for a little while," she said. "I don't care if you're not equal to me for a while."
George weighed the bag with his hands. "I don't mind it," he said. "I don't notice it any more. It's just a part of me."
"You been so tired lately-kind of wore out," said Hazel. "If there was just some way we could make a little hole in the bottom of the bag, and just take out a few of them lead balls. Just a few."
"Two years in prison and two thousand dollars fine for every ball I took out," said George. "I don't call that a bargain."
"If you could just take a few out when you came home from work," said Hazel. "I mean-you don't compete with anybody around here. You just set around."
"If I tried to get away with it," said George, "then other people'd get away with it-and pretty soon we'd be right back to the dark ages again, with everybody competing against everybody else. You wouldn't like that, would you?"
"I'd hate it," said Hazel.
"There you are," said George. The minute people start cheating on laws, what do you think happens to society?"
If Hazel hadn't been able to come up with an answer to this question, George couldn't have supplied one. A siren was going off in his head.
"Reckon it'd fall all apart," said Hazel.
"What would?" said George blankly.
"Society," said Hazel uncertainly. "Wasn't that what you just said?
"Who knows?" said George.
The television program was suddenly interrupted for a news bulletin. It wasn't clear at first as to what the bulletin was about, since the announcer, like all announcers, had a serious speech impediment. For about half a minute, and in a state of high excitement, the announcer tried to say, "Ladies and Gentlemen."
He finally gave up, handed the bulletin to a ballerina to read.
"That's all right-" Hazel said of the announcer, "he tried. That's the big thing. He tried to do the best he could with what God gave him. He should get a nice raise for trying so hard."
"Ladies and Gentlemen," said the ballerina, reading the bulletin. She must have been extraordinarily beautiful, because the mask she wore was hideous. And it was easy to see that she was the strongest and most graceful of all the dancers, for her handicap bags were as big as those worn by two-hundred pound men.
And she had to apologize at once for her voice, which was a very unfair voice for a woman to use. Her voice was a warm, luminous, timeless melody. "Excuse me-" she said, and she began again, making her voice absolutely uncompetitive.
"Harrison Bergeron, age fourteen," she said in a grackle squawk, "has just escaped from jail, where he was held on suspicion of plotting to overthrow the government. He is a genius and an athlete, is under-handicapped, and should be regarded as extremely dangerous."
A police photograph of Harrison Bergeron was flashed on the screen-upside down, then sideways, upside down again, then right side up. The picture showed the full length of Harrison against a background calibrated in feet and inches. He was exactly seven feet tall.
The rest of Harrison's appearance was Halloween and hardware. Nobody had ever born heavier handicaps. He had outgrown hindrances faster than the H-G men could think them up. Instead of a little ear radio for a mental handicap, he wore a tremendous pair of earphones, and spectacles with thick wavy lenses. The spectacles were intended to make him not only half blind, but to give him whanging headaches besides.
Scrap metal was hung all over him. Ordinarily, there was a certain symmetry, a military neatness to the handicaps issued to strong people, but Harrison looked like a walking junkyard. In the race of life, Harrison carried three hundred pounds.
And to offset his good looks, the H-G men required that he wear at all times a red rubber ball for a nose, keep his eyebrows shaved off, and cover his even white teeth with black caps at snaggle-tooth random.
"If you see this boy," said the ballerina, "do not - I repeat, do not - try to reason with him."
There was the shriek of a door being torn from its hinges.
Screams and barking cries of consternation came from the television set. The photograph of Harrison Bergeron on the screen jumped again and again, as though dancing to the tune of an earthquake.
George Bergeron correctly identified the earthquake, and well he might have - for many was the time his own home had danced to the same crashing tune. "My God-" said George, "that must be Harrison!"
The realization was blasted from his mind instantly by the sound of an automobile collision in his head.
When George could open his eyes again, the photograph of Harrison was gone. A living, breathing Harrison filled the screen.
Clanking, clownish, and huge, Harrison stood - in the center of the studio. The knob of the uprooted studio door was still in his hand. Ballerinas, technicians, musicians, and announcers cowered on their knees before him, expecting to die.
"I am the Emperor!" cried Harrison. "Do you hear? I am the Emperor! Everybody must do what I say at once!" He stamped his foot and the studio shook.
"Even as I stand here" he bellowed, "crippled, hobbled, sickened - I am a greater ruler than any man who ever lived! Now watch me become what I can become!"
Harrison tore the straps of his handicap harness like wet tissue paper, tore straps guaranteed to support five thousand pounds.
Harrison's scrap-iron handicaps crashed to the floor.
Harrison thrust his thumbs under the bar of the padlock that secured his head harness. The bar snapped like celery. Harrison smashed his headphones and spectacles against the wall.
He flung away his rubber-ball nose, revealed a man that would have awed Thor, the god of thunder.
"I shall now select my Empress!" he said, looking down on the cowering people. "Let the first woman who dares rise to her feet claim her mate and her throne!"
A moment passed, and then a ballerina arose, swaying like a willow.
Harrison plucked the mental handicap from her ear, snapped off her physical handicaps with marvelous delicacy. Last of all he removed her mask.
She was blindingly beautiful.
"Now-" said Harrison, taking her hand, "shall we show the people the meaning of the word dance? Music!" he commanded.
The musicians scrambled back into their chairs, and Harrison stripped them of their handicaps, too. "Play your best," he told them, "and I'll make you barons and dukes and earls."
The music began. It was normal at first-cheap, silly, false. But Harrison snatched two musicians from their chairs, waved them like batons as he sang the music as he wanted it played. He slammed them back into their chairs.
The music began again and was much improved.
Harrison and his Empress merely listened to the music for a while-listened gravely, as though synchronizing their heartbeats with it.
They shifted their weights to their toes.
Harrison placed his big hands on the girls tiny waist, letting her sense the weightlessness that would soon be hers.
And then, in an explosion of joy and grace, into the air they sprang!
Not only were the laws of the land abandoned, but the law of gravity and the laws of motion as well.
They reeled, whirled, swiveled, flounced, capered, gamboled, and spun.
They leaped like deer on the moon.
The studio ceiling was thirty feet high, but each leap brought the dancers nearer to it.
It became their obvious intention to kiss the ceiling. They kissed it.
And then, neutraling gravity with love and pure will, they remained suspended in air inches below the ceiling, and they kissed each other for a long, long time.
It was then that Diana Moon Glampers, the Handicapper General, came into the studio with a double-barreled ten-gauge shotgun. She fired twice, and the Emperor and the Empress were dead before they hit the floor.
Diana Moon Glampers loaded the gun again. She aimed it at the musicians and told them they had ten seconds to get their handicaps back on.
It was then that the Bergerons' television tube burned out.
Hazel turned to comment about the blackout to George. But George had gone out into the kitchen for a can of beer.
George came back in with the beer, paused while a handicap signal shook him up. And then he sat down again. "You been crying" he said to Hazel.
"Yup," she said.
"What about?" he said.
"I forget," she said. "Something real sad on television."
"What was it?" he said.
"It's all kind of mixed up in my mind," said Hazel.
"Forget sad things," said George.
"I always do," said Hazel.
"That's my girl," said George. He winced. There was the sound of a rivetting gun in his head.
"Gee - I could tell that one was a doozy," said Hazel.
"You can say that again," said George.
"Gee-" said Hazel, "I could tell that one was a doozy."
"Harrison Bergeron", by Kurt Vonnegut, Jr., 1961
THE YEAR WAS 2081, and everybody was finally equal. They weren't only equal before God and the law. They were equal every which way. Nobody was smarter than anybody else. Nobody was better looking than anybody else. Nobody was stronger or quicker than anybody else. All this equality was due to the 211th, 212th, and 213th Amendments to the Constitution, and to the unceasing vigilance of agents of the United States Handicapper General.
Some things about living still weren't quite right, though. April for instance, still drove people crazy by not being springtime. And it was in that clammy month that the H-G men took George and Hazel Bergeron's fourteen-year-old son, Harrison, away.
It was tragic, all right, but George and Hazel couldn't think about it very hard. Hazel had a perfectly average intelligence, which meant she couldn't think about anything except in short bursts. And George, while his intelligence was way above normal, had a little mental handicap radio in his ear. He was required by law to wear it at all times. It was tuned to a government transmitter. Every twenty seconds or so, the transmitter would send out some sharp noise to keep people like George from taking unfair advantage of their brains.
George and Hazel were watching television. There were tears on Hazel's cheeks, but she'd forgotten for the moment what they were about.
On the television screen were ballerinas.
A buzzer sounded in George's head. His thoughts fled in panic, like bandits from a burglar alarm.
"That was a real pretty dance, that dance they just did," said Hazel.
"Huh" said George.
"That dance-it was nice," said Hazel.
"Yup," said George. He tried to think a little about the ballerinas. They weren't really very good-no better than anybody else would have been, anyway. They were burdened with sashweights and bags of birdshot, and their faces were masked, so that no one, seeing a free and graceful gesture or a pretty face, would feel like something the cat drug in. George was toying with the vague notion that maybe dancers shouldn't be handicapped. But he didn't get very far with it before another noise in his ear radio scattered his thoughts.
George winced. So did two out of the eight ballerinas.
Hazel saw him wince. Having no mental handicap herself, she had to ask George what the latest sound had been.
"Sounded like somebody hitting a milk bottle with a ball peen hammer," said George.
"I'd think it would be real interesting, hearing all the different sounds," said Hazel a little envious. "All the things they think up."
"Um," said George.
"Only, if I was Handicapper General, you know what I would do?" said Hazel. Hazel, as a matter of fact, bore a strong resemblance to the Handicapper General, a woman named Diana Moon Glampers. "If I was Diana Moon Glampers," said Hazel, "I'd have chimes on Sunday-just chimes. Kind of in honor of religion."
"I could think, if it was just chimes," said George.
"Well-maybe make 'em real loud," said Hazel. "I think I'd make a good Handicapper General."
"Good as anybody else," said George.
"Who knows better then I do what normal is?" said Hazel.
"Right," said George. He began to think glimmeringly about his abnormal son who was now in jail, about Harrison, but a twenty-one-gun salute in his head stopped that.
"Boy!" said Hazel, "that was a doozy, wasn't it?"
It was such a doozy that George was white and trembling, and tears stood on the rims of his red eyes. Two of of the eight ballerinas had collapsed to the studio floor, were holding their temples.
"All of a sudden you look so tired," said Hazel. "Why don't you stretch out on the sofa, so's you can rest your handicap bag on the pillows, honeybunch." She was referring to the forty-seven pounds of birdshot in a canvas bag, which was padlocked around George's neck. "Go on and rest the bag for a little while," she said. "I don't care if you're not equal to me for a while."
George weighed the bag with his hands. "I don't mind it," he said. "I don't notice it any more. It's just a part of me."
"You been so tired lately-kind of wore out," said Hazel. "If there was just some way we could make a little hole in the bottom of the bag, and just take out a few of them lead balls. Just a few."
"Two years in prison and two thousand dollars fine for every ball I took out," said George. "I don't call that a bargain."
"If you could just take a few out when you came home from work," said Hazel. "I mean-you don't compete with anybody around here. You just set around."
"If I tried to get away with it," said George, "then other people'd get away with it-and pretty soon we'd be right back to the dark ages again, with everybody competing against everybody else. You wouldn't like that, would you?"
"I'd hate it," said Hazel.
"There you are," said George. The minute people start cheating on laws, what do you think happens to society?"
If Hazel hadn't been able to come up with an answer to this question, George couldn't have supplied one. A siren was going off in his head.
"Reckon it'd fall all apart," said Hazel.
"What would?" said George blankly.
"Society," said Hazel uncertainly. "Wasn't that what you just said?
"Who knows?" said George.
The television program was suddenly interrupted for a news bulletin. It wasn't clear at first as to what the bulletin was about, since the announcer, like all announcers, had a serious speech impediment. For about half a minute, and in a state of high excitement, the announcer tried to say, "Ladies and Gentlemen."
He finally gave up, handed the bulletin to a ballerina to read.
"That's all right-" Hazel said of the announcer, "he tried. That's the big thing. He tried to do the best he could with what God gave him. He should get a nice raise for trying so hard."
"Ladies and Gentlemen," said the ballerina, reading the bulletin. She must have been extraordinarily beautiful, because the mask she wore was hideous. And it was easy to see that she was the strongest and most graceful of all the dancers, for her handicap bags were as big as those worn by two-hundred pound men.
And she had to apologize at once for her voice, which was a very unfair voice for a woman to use. Her voice was a warm, luminous, timeless melody. "Excuse me-" she said, and she began again, making her voice absolutely uncompetitive.
"Harrison Bergeron, age fourteen," she said in a grackle squawk, "has just escaped from jail, where he was held on suspicion of plotting to overthrow the government. He is a genius and an athlete, is under-handicapped, and should be regarded as extremely dangerous."
A police photograph of Harrison Bergeron was flashed on the screen-upside down, then sideways, upside down again, then right side up. The picture showed the full length of Harrison against a background calibrated in feet and inches. He was exactly seven feet tall.
The rest of Harrison's appearance was Halloween and hardware. Nobody had ever born heavier handicaps. He had outgrown hindrances faster than the H-G men could think them up. Instead of a little ear radio for a mental handicap, he wore a tremendous pair of earphones, and spectacles with thick wavy lenses. The spectacles were intended to make him not only half blind, but to give him whanging headaches besides.
Scrap metal was hung all over him. Ordinarily, there was a certain symmetry, a military neatness to the handicaps issued to strong people, but Harrison looked like a walking junkyard. In the race of life, Harrison carried three hundred pounds.
And to offset his good looks, the H-G men required that he wear at all times a red rubber ball for a nose, keep his eyebrows shaved off, and cover his even white teeth with black caps at snaggle-tooth random.
"If you see this boy," said the ballerina, "do not - I repeat, do not - try to reason with him."
There was the shriek of a door being torn from its hinges.
Screams and barking cries of consternation came from the television set. The photograph of Harrison Bergeron on the screen jumped again and again, as though dancing to the tune of an earthquake.
George Bergeron correctly identified the earthquake, and well he might have - for many was the time his own home had danced to the same crashing tune. "My God-" said George, "that must be Harrison!"
The realization was blasted from his mind instantly by the sound of an automobile collision in his head.
When George could open his eyes again, the photograph of Harrison was gone. A living, breathing Harrison filled the screen.
Clanking, clownish, and huge, Harrison stood - in the center of the studio. The knob of the uprooted studio door was still in his hand. Ballerinas, technicians, musicians, and announcers cowered on their knees before him, expecting to die.
"I am the Emperor!" cried Harrison. "Do you hear? I am the Emperor! Everybody must do what I say at once!" He stamped his foot and the studio shook.
"Even as I stand here" he bellowed, "crippled, hobbled, sickened - I am a greater ruler than any man who ever lived! Now watch me become what I can become!"
Harrison tore the straps of his handicap harness like wet tissue paper, tore straps guaranteed to support five thousand pounds.
Harrison's scrap-iron handicaps crashed to the floor.
Harrison thrust his thumbs under the bar of the padlock that secured his head harness. The bar snapped like celery. Harrison smashed his headphones and spectacles against the wall.
He flung away his rubber-ball nose, revealed a man that would have awed Thor, the god of thunder.
"I shall now select my Empress!" he said, looking down on the cowering people. "Let the first woman who dares rise to her feet claim her mate and her throne!"
A moment passed, and then a ballerina arose, swaying like a willow.
Harrison plucked the mental handicap from her ear, snapped off her physical handicaps with marvelous delicacy. Last of all he removed her mask.
She was blindingly beautiful.
"Now-" said Harrison, taking her hand, "shall we show the people the meaning of the word dance? Music!" he commanded.
The musicians scrambled back into their chairs, and Harrison stripped them of their handicaps, too. "Play your best," he told them, "and I'll make you barons and dukes and earls."
The music began. It was normal at first-cheap, silly, false. But Harrison snatched two musicians from their chairs, waved them like batons as he sang the music as he wanted it played. He slammed them back into their chairs.
The music began again and was much improved.
Harrison and his Empress merely listened to the music for a while-listened gravely, as though synchronizing their heartbeats with it.
They shifted their weights to their toes.
Harrison placed his big hands on the girls tiny waist, letting her sense the weightlessness that would soon be hers.
And then, in an explosion of joy and grace, into the air they sprang!
Not only were the laws of the land abandoned, but the law of gravity and the laws of motion as well.
They reeled, whirled, swiveled, flounced, capered, gamboled, and spun.
They leaped like deer on the moon.
The studio ceiling was thirty feet high, but each leap brought the dancers nearer to it.
It became their obvious intention to kiss the ceiling. They kissed it.
And then, neutraling gravity with love and pure will, they remained suspended in air inches below the ceiling, and they kissed each other for a long, long time.
It was then that Diana Moon Glampers, the Handicapper General, came into the studio with a double-barreled ten-gauge shotgun. She fired twice, and the Emperor and the Empress were dead before they hit the floor.
Diana Moon Glampers loaded the gun again. She aimed it at the musicians and told them they had ten seconds to get their handicaps back on.
It was then that the Bergerons' television tube burned out.
Hazel turned to comment about the blackout to George. But George had gone out into the kitchen for a can of beer.
George came back in with the beer, paused while a handicap signal shook him up. And then he sat down again. "You been crying" he said to Hazel.
"Yup," she said.
"What about?" he said.
"I forget," she said. "Something real sad on television."
"What was it?" he said.
"It's all kind of mixed up in my mind," said Hazel.
"Forget sad things," said George.
"I always do," said Hazel.
"That's my girl," said George. He winced. There was the sound of a rivetting gun in his head.
"Gee - I could tell that one was a doozy," said Hazel.
"You can say that again," said George.
"Gee-" said Hazel, "I could tell that one was a doozy."
Tuesday, April 6, 2010
Nietzsche on the Gift
I just "Stumbled Upon" (I highly recommend this application for anyone who hasn't heard of it) a compilation of 40 "belief-shaking remarks" by Nietzsche. The first one was:
"People who have given us their complete confidence believe that they have a right to ours. The inference is false, a gift confers no rights."
I found this latter part pretty interesting. As Matt had mentioned, when he gave his bike away he expected that the receiver take good care of it, use it well, enjoy it, tell him about his adventures on it, etc. But are these rights? I suppose not, but as we've talked about, it would certainly discourage more gift giving.
Thoughts?
(The whole list can be found at http://www.raptitude.com/2010/03/40-belief-shaking-remarks-from-a-ruthless-nonconformist/ )
"People who have given us their complete confidence believe that they have a right to ours. The inference is false, a gift confers no rights."
I found this latter part pretty interesting. As Matt had mentioned, when he gave his bike away he expected that the receiver take good care of it, use it well, enjoy it, tell him about his adventures on it, etc. But are these rights? I suppose not, but as we've talked about, it would certainly discourage more gift giving.
Thoughts?
(The whole list can be found at http://www.raptitude.com/2010/03/40-belief-shaking-remarks-from-a-ruthless-nonconformist/ )
Friday, March 26, 2010
Animals as Property
Here's my paper for the course. For some reason the footnotes didn't copy/paste over.
Humans cannot rightfully be the owners of animals. By “rightful,” I mean that humans do not have a morally valid claim to call animals their property or to enact legislation that makes animals their property. By “owners” of an animal, I mean people who have the right to possess, control, breed, sell, and decide the fate of an animal. This is similar to our society’s widespread belief that humans cannot be the property of other humans.
The law and legal systems have contributed to the way that humans think of animals as their property. In common and civil law, there are two entities: persons and things. In law, animals are considered things and not persons, and are therefore able to be the property of humans. As Professor Reinold Noyes writes, “legal relations in our law exist only between persons. There cannot be a legal relation between a person and a thing or between two things.” This is a major reason that animals are treated as property in our society.
One example of animals being treated as property in the courtroom is the case of DeSanctis v. Pritchard, in which a married couple had a pet dog named Barney. The couple divorced, and court decided that Barney would become the property of the wife, but allowed the husband the right to visit the dog. However, when the wife moved away and the husband could not see Barney anymore, he sued for partial custody. The judge ruled that visitation agreement for a dog was “like a visitation agreement for a table or a lamp,” and denied the husband’s request.
There are also historical, cultural, religious, and economic reasons for considering animals the property of humans. Humans have considered animals as property for so long that many people never stop to consider it. Many religions and belief systems proclaim that humans are superior and nonhumans are inferior. Additionally, “animal exploitation is a billion-dollar industry – and human beings appear to be able to justify most actions that result in monetary gain.”
However, animals are different from property because they are alive and sentient. Though sentience is an area of contention in the animal rights debate, it is beyond the scope of this paper to argue it and for the purpose of this thesis I will assume that animals are sentient.
Animals are already treated somewhat differently from other forms of property through legislation like anti-cruelty laws. While someone can do whatever she pleases with a table that she owns, even punch it or break it in two if she is angry, she could not legally do this to an animal. People are not allowed to torture, neglect, or kill animals in any way that is inhumane or unnecessary. In fact, every state now has a law that protects animals from unnecessary cruelty.
However, “almost every such statute contains specific exemptions for virtually all forms of institutionalized animal exploitation, such as the use of animals for food, scientific experiments, hunting and trapping.” The problem is that what constitutes “unnecessary cruelty” is an ambiguous term. Francione writes, “as long as we accept that it is morally permissible for humans to eat nonhumans, then, if the dehorning or castration of animals is what is thought to make the animal more fit for that human use, the conduct will be deemed as ‘necessary’.”
This is not to say that one cannot rightfully be the guardian or caregiver to an animal. Because humans are more advanced, they can do things in the interest of the animals who cannot think into the future and therefore cannot provide for themselves as well as humans can provide for them. People have duties and obligations towards animals of whom they are caregivers, but being in charge of an animal is different from owning one. Also, changing the property status of animals would not prevent people from having pets. There are some states that have changed the terminology in their legislation from being the “owner” of an animal to a “guardian” of an animal, which might signal a movement away from the idea of animals as property.
I suspect that there is an increasing level of obligation with ownership. Non-living things like cars and books have indirect links to life; for example, one has obligations to drive a car carefully because a crash may kill someone. Owning land is a direct link with life and therefore one more step of responsibility. A step beyond that would be owning an animal, and the furthest step would be owning a fellow human. In cases of humans owning humans, though they were both the same species, the owner believed or convinced himself that the humans he owned were somehow below him. In our society, we view humans owning humans as wrong and immoral, but most fail to see how similar this is to humans owning animals.
One may object to this thesis by saying that animals are not persons because they lack certain important qualities like self-reflection, language, etc. Since our legal system includes only two entities – persons and things – and animals are not persons, then they are things.
I do not think that animals should be awarded the exact same rights that humans have (as Peter Singer wrote: “Since a pig can’t vote, it is meaningless to talk of its right to vote.”) , but perhaps there should be a new entity created in our legal system, so as to include persons, animals, and then things.
Additionally, in regards to those qualities which would make animals non-persons, there are certain humans who also lack these qualities (people in vegetative states, people with severe brain injury, etc.). However, because these humans are humans, they are considered to be persons by most, and are certainly not owned by anyone.
Humans cannot rightfully be the owners of animals. By “rightful,” I mean that humans do not have a morally valid claim to call animals their property or to enact legislation that makes animals their property. By “owners” of an animal, I mean people who have the right to possess, control, breed, sell, and decide the fate of an animal. This is similar to our society’s widespread belief that humans cannot be the property of other humans.
The law and legal systems have contributed to the way that humans think of animals as their property. In common and civil law, there are two entities: persons and things. In law, animals are considered things and not persons, and are therefore able to be the property of humans. As Professor Reinold Noyes writes, “legal relations in our law exist only between persons. There cannot be a legal relation between a person and a thing or between two things.” This is a major reason that animals are treated as property in our society.
One example of animals being treated as property in the courtroom is the case of DeSanctis v. Pritchard, in which a married couple had a pet dog named Barney. The couple divorced, and court decided that Barney would become the property of the wife, but allowed the husband the right to visit the dog. However, when the wife moved away and the husband could not see Barney anymore, he sued for partial custody. The judge ruled that visitation agreement for a dog was “like a visitation agreement for a table or a lamp,” and denied the husband’s request.
There are also historical, cultural, religious, and economic reasons for considering animals the property of humans. Humans have considered animals as property for so long that many people never stop to consider it. Many religions and belief systems proclaim that humans are superior and nonhumans are inferior. Additionally, “animal exploitation is a billion-dollar industry – and human beings appear to be able to justify most actions that result in monetary gain.”
However, animals are different from property because they are alive and sentient. Though sentience is an area of contention in the animal rights debate, it is beyond the scope of this paper to argue it and for the purpose of this thesis I will assume that animals are sentient.
Animals are already treated somewhat differently from other forms of property through legislation like anti-cruelty laws. While someone can do whatever she pleases with a table that she owns, even punch it or break it in two if she is angry, she could not legally do this to an animal. People are not allowed to torture, neglect, or kill animals in any way that is inhumane or unnecessary. In fact, every state now has a law that protects animals from unnecessary cruelty.
However, “almost every such statute contains specific exemptions for virtually all forms of institutionalized animal exploitation, such as the use of animals for food, scientific experiments, hunting and trapping.” The problem is that what constitutes “unnecessary cruelty” is an ambiguous term. Francione writes, “as long as we accept that it is morally permissible for humans to eat nonhumans, then, if the dehorning or castration of animals is what is thought to make the animal more fit for that human use, the conduct will be deemed as ‘necessary’.”
This is not to say that one cannot rightfully be the guardian or caregiver to an animal. Because humans are more advanced, they can do things in the interest of the animals who cannot think into the future and therefore cannot provide for themselves as well as humans can provide for them. People have duties and obligations towards animals of whom they are caregivers, but being in charge of an animal is different from owning one. Also, changing the property status of animals would not prevent people from having pets. There are some states that have changed the terminology in their legislation from being the “owner” of an animal to a “guardian” of an animal, which might signal a movement away from the idea of animals as property.
I suspect that there is an increasing level of obligation with ownership. Non-living things like cars and books have indirect links to life; for example, one has obligations to drive a car carefully because a crash may kill someone. Owning land is a direct link with life and therefore one more step of responsibility. A step beyond that would be owning an animal, and the furthest step would be owning a fellow human. In cases of humans owning humans, though they were both the same species, the owner believed or convinced himself that the humans he owned were somehow below him. In our society, we view humans owning humans as wrong and immoral, but most fail to see how similar this is to humans owning animals.
One may object to this thesis by saying that animals are not persons because they lack certain important qualities like self-reflection, language, etc. Since our legal system includes only two entities – persons and things – and animals are not persons, then they are things.
I do not think that animals should be awarded the exact same rights that humans have (as Peter Singer wrote: “Since a pig can’t vote, it is meaningless to talk of its right to vote.”) , but perhaps there should be a new entity created in our legal system, so as to include persons, animals, and then things.
Additionally, in regards to those qualities which would make animals non-persons, there are certain humans who also lack these qualities (people in vegetative states, people with severe brain injury, etc.). However, because these humans are humans, they are considered to be persons by most, and are certainly not owned by anyone.
Saturday, March 6, 2010
Subsistence and Security
We didn't get a chance to talk about my SLAP last week, and I'm curious as to what everyone else thinks about it. I suppose I'll just recreate it here:
S: What would happen when subsistence and security contradict?
L: "It will sometimes happen that a measure suggested by one of these principles will be condemned by another...When this contradiction exists between two of these ends, it is necessary to find some means of deciding the pre-eminence...At the first glance we see subsistence and security arising together to the same level; abundance and equality are manifestly of inferior importance. In face, without security, equality could not last a day; without subsistence, abundance could not exist at all. The two first objects are life itself; the two latter, the ornaments of life." (Chapter II, pp. 42-43)
A: Bentham says that "In legislation, the most important object is security" (43), but does not identify which is more important for happiness. He makes it clear that subsistence and security are more foundational than security and eqaulity, but if a situation arose in which one had to benefit and one had to suffer, he does not specify what is right in that case.
P: Which takes precedence for Bentham: subsistence or security?
S: What would happen when subsistence and security contradict?
L: "It will sometimes happen that a measure suggested by one of these principles will be condemned by another...When this contradiction exists between two of these ends, it is necessary to find some means of deciding the pre-eminence...At the first glance we see subsistence and security arising together to the same level; abundance and equality are manifestly of inferior importance. In face, without security, equality could not last a day; without subsistence, abundance could not exist at all. The two first objects are life itself; the two latter, the ornaments of life." (Chapter II, pp. 42-43)
A: Bentham says that "In legislation, the most important object is security" (43), but does not identify which is more important for happiness. He makes it clear that subsistence and security are more foundational than security and eqaulity, but if a situation arose in which one had to benefit and one had to suffer, he does not specify what is right in that case.
P: Which takes precedence for Bentham: subsistence or security?
Sunday, February 21, 2010
Rousseau and Government
While reading Rousseau, it seemed as though he was against all forms of government and civilization. He claims, "it is iron and wheat which have civilized men and ruined the human race" (32). He speaks as if nothing good came from the civilization of humankind. When speaking of government, he writes, "All ran to meet their chains thinking they secured their freedom..." (36).
Does Rousseau oppose all government? I realize that this is just an excerpt, so I suppose he could clarify later.
Does Rousseau oppose all government? I realize that this is just an excerpt, so I suppose he could clarify later.
Sunday, February 14, 2010
Land Ownership
After our Owning and Belonging class on Monday, I went home and read out of "The Earth Knows My Name" by Patricia Klindienst. It's a collection of tales about "food, culture, and sustainability in the gardens of ethnic Americans." I'm reading the book for my Director's Book Course. With property on my mind, I had an interesting perspective on the book (I love when ideas from two classes merge together!).
While describing the Gullah people of South Carolina, she notes that the man she's interviewing, Ralph, "never uses the word property or mine in speaking of [his land]." He says that the Gullah "feel that we are part of the land." Ralph also expresses his distaste for gated communities and fences around property, saying, "everybody here was raised to feel free to walk anywhere," and, "Here, you respect a person's land."
I think that perhaps this is what we need to try to get back to. We need a basic respect for people and to see land as more than a commodity. I think as a culture we have lost touch with the land, and certainly don't "feel that we are a part of the land" as the Gullah do. We need to get back to our literal and figurative roots in the land.
While describing the Gullah people of South Carolina, she notes that the man she's interviewing, Ralph, "never uses the word property or mine in speaking of [his land]." He says that the Gullah "feel that we are part of the land." Ralph also expresses his distaste for gated communities and fences around property, saying, "everybody here was raised to feel free to walk anywhere," and, "Here, you respect a person's land."
I think that perhaps this is what we need to try to get back to. We need a basic respect for people and to see land as more than a commodity. I think as a culture we have lost touch with the land, and certainly don't "feel that we are a part of the land" as the Gullah do. We need to get back to our literal and figurative roots in the land.
Sunday, February 7, 2010
Possession v. Ownership
I was thinking about the difference between possessing something and owning something today. Just for clarification: (from dictionary.com) Possession: Law. actual holding or occupancy, either with or without rights of ownership. Ownership: 1. the state or fact of being an owner. 2.legal right of possession; proprietorship.
So clearly just because we possess something does not mean we own it. However, we've all heard the saying "possession is 9 points of the law." Ownership is a mental construct, while possession is something physical.
This makes me wonder about the origin of ownership. I wonder when earlier humans made the distinction between ownership and possession? It seems as though language is required to have ownership rather than possession, since ownership requires more than one person. Do animals distinguish between the two?
So clearly just because we possess something does not mean we own it. However, we've all heard the saying "possession is 9 points of the law." Ownership is a mental construct, while possession is something physical.
This makes me wonder about the origin of ownership. I wonder when earlier humans made the distinction between ownership and possession? It seems as though language is required to have ownership rather than possession, since ownership requires more than one person. Do animals distinguish between the two?
Sunday, January 31, 2010
Owning Land & AIr
People have been talking about owning land on Skeptiblog. Land, to me, seems like too basic an element of life to be something that can be owned. Perhaps that is because it is not as tangible as things that I normally think of owning--a book, clothes, a house, etc. How far down does one's owned land go, anyhow? All the way to the center of the earth? Just a thought.
Anyhow, this reminded me of Peter Barnes' Sky Trust. Here's a link if you've not heard of it: . Does something have to be tangible and outlined in order to be owned? Or, as Tania suggested, does it have to do with usage?
There was something that troubled me in Locke's chapter about property. He speaks of a man picking up acorns under an oak. Because the man has put his labor into appropriating the acorns, they belong to him. However, it makes no mention of that situation of someone else owns the tree. So if Brendon decided to be rebellious and take that picnic on private property, and took some acorns from underneath a tree, wouldn't that be stealing? Would the simple act of him being on the land be stealing?
Anyhow, this reminded me of Peter Barnes' Sky Trust. Here's a link if you've not heard of it: . Does something have to be tangible and outlined in order to be owned? Or, as Tania suggested, does it have to do with usage?
There was something that troubled me in Locke's chapter about property. He speaks of a man picking up acorns under an oak. Because the man has put his labor into appropriating the acorns, they belong to him. However, it makes no mention of that situation of someone else owns the tree. So if Brendon decided to be rebellious and take that picnic on private property, and took some acorns from underneath a tree, wouldn't that be stealing? Would the simple act of him being on the land be stealing?
Tuesday, January 26, 2010
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)