Saturday, November 14, 2009

Response to Alyson Carey

This week, Alyson asked, "Is there a set standard for taste?"

Hume writes that "it is natural for us to seep a Standard of Taste; a rule, by which the various sentiments of men may be reconciled; at least, a decision, afforded, conforming one sentiment, and condemning another" (42).

What I've read of my book review book (Taste: The Secret Meaning of Things, by Stephen Bayley) so far suggests a few things about the standard of taste. Firstly, we are all influenced by the taste of our times. Norman Bel Geddes suggests that if Keats had been writing during the 1940s, his famous poem would have written about an automobile or plane, rather than the Grecian Urn. Bayley claims that money and taste are inseparable, as are class and taste. Finally, according the Bayley, "the one certain thing about taste is that it changes."

My answer to this question is that no, there is not a set standard for taste. I agree with the statement Hume alludes to and disagrees with -- that there is no disputing about taste. Yes, tastes do change and rely on multiple factors such as education, class, status, wealth, and country of origin...but to set a standard for taste, in my opinion, would be impossible and pointless.

Hume

When I researched Hume in the Stanford online dictionary of philosophy (), I thought some of his ideas were pretty interesting. One of the things I found most interesting was Hume's "copy principle," which I think is pretty confusing, but might still apply to what we've read about Hume and art. I will try to paraphrase...

Perceptions come in two different types: ideas (more feeble) and impressions. Hume's copy principle says that complex ideas are composed of simple ideas, which are in turn faint copies of simple impressions from which they are derived, to which they correspond and resemble. He then provides the "missing shade of blue" contradiction, which I think discredits the entire principle, but nevertheless...

Hume then applies this principle (in reverse) to definitions. He thought that in order to define, you needed to "pass from words to the true and real subject of the controversy." You begin with the term, then ask yourself what term is annexed to it. If there is none, then the term has no cognitive content. If there is, you break that into simple ideas and trace it back to its original impressions.

I wish Hume had talked about this explicitly when he discussed art. Hume doesn't even attempt to define art, he simply presents the reader with his antinomy, and then proceeds to explain art as an object of taste. I think that if Hume had applied his reverse copy principle in an attempt to define art, this essay would have had more substance.

Hume alludes to the saying, "There is no disputing about taste," and seems to disagree with it. He says that if one has a taste that is clearly inferior, "no one pays attention to such a taste..." (43) This has not convinced me--do you think Hume is wrong to dismiss others' tastes?