Sunday, February 21, 2010

Rousseau and Government

While reading Rousseau, it seemed as though he was against all forms of government and civilization. He claims, "it is iron and wheat which have civilized men and ruined the human race" (32). He speaks as if nothing good came from the civilization of humankind. When speaking of government, he writes, "All ran to meet their chains thinking they secured their freedom..." (36).

Does Rousseau oppose all government? I realize that this is just an excerpt, so I suppose he could clarify later.

4 comments:

  1. I think he's more opposed to the negative effects of owning property (namely the resulting inequality of people) than he is to being "civilized" or having any kind of government.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Fairly consistently throughout his writing, Rousseau presents a sort of tragic, nostalgic image of civilized humanity as irredeemably corrupted or fallen (I'm surely not the first to note the religious resonance of this tragic sensibility, even in this most secular of thinkers). It's not that he doesn't think we should make the best of our degraded, civilized condition, proposing principles for doing so in his essay on the Social Contract, and a detailed program for educating people to negotiate the paradox between natural freedom and necessary conformity to society (Emile).

    So he seems to think property (in land specifically) is a necessary concomitant of civilization, and that we're stuck with civilization for better and much worse. Inequality is thus an ugly fact that we are stuck with. Such pessimism may not seem particularly constructive...

    ReplyDelete
  3. He certainly took a dark perspective when discussing civilization. He said that "...more murders were committed on a single day of fighting and more horrors in the capture of a single city than were committed in the state of nature during whole centuries over the entire face of the earth. Such are the first effects one glimpses of the division of the human race into different societies" (Macpherson 37). His argument, though bleak, is highly subjective, especially because he tended to turn progress on its head and call it the death of pure humanity. But what did he think was pure about humans living in a state of nature? According to Locke, in a state of nature, man is not secure. The reason we have civilization is to create security of the things we own and of the lives we possess.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Rousseau's writings like anyone else's also seems to heavily shaped from what he experienced through his life. If you read the Confession's there seem to be some links between why he thought the way he about certain things, especially between his thoughts on the arts and the sciences and his early youth.

    ReplyDelete