Saturday, March 6, 2010

Subsistence and Security

We didn't get a chance to talk about my SLAP last week, and I'm curious as to what everyone else thinks about it. I suppose I'll just recreate it here:

S: What would happen when subsistence and security contradict?
L: "It will sometimes happen that a measure suggested by one of these principles will be condemned by another...When this contradiction exists between two of these ends, it is necessary to find some means of deciding the pre-eminence...At the first glance we see subsistence and security arising together to the same level; abundance and equality are manifestly of inferior importance. In face, without security, equality could not last a day; without subsistence, abundance could not exist at all. The two first objects are life itself; the two latter, the ornaments of life." (Chapter II, pp. 42-43)
A: Bentham says that "In legislation, the most important object is security" (43), but does not identify which is more important for happiness. He makes it clear that subsistence and security are more foundational than security and eqaulity, but if a situation arose in which one had to benefit and one had to suffer, he does not specify what is right in that case.
P: Which takes precedence for Bentham: subsistence or security?