Sunday, November 1, 2009

Response to Fay Bartow

Fay asked: Can aesthetic emotion actually become a common emotion--can it wear its significance out?

I actually think that an aesthetic emotion is a common emotion. I suspect that John Dewey would certainly agree with me. Fay says that common emotions are those that we come in contact with every day...I think the same can be said for aesthetic emotions. As Professor Johnson said, seeing that one dirty fork left in the sink of an otherwise perfectly clean kitchen can be considered an aesthetic emotion, and it is certainly a common emotion (I wish my kitchen sink only had one dirty fork...).

I also think that aesthetic emotion, like other common emotions, is something that can be exercised. That is to say--you aren't born with a certain amount of love, which you use up and then you're out of love. When you love, you generate more love, and act more lovingly. By exercising an emotion, you create more of it, rather than using it up. I think this can certainly be applied to aesthetic emotions.

Moving to Weitz...
What do you think about Weitz's view that there are no necessary and sufficient attributes of art, but you can recognize it when you see it? ...That, *this*, *this*, *this*, and 'similar things' are art? Is this a satisfactory explanation for you?