Tuesday, April 6, 2010

Nietzsche on the Gift

I just "Stumbled Upon" (I highly recommend this application for anyone who hasn't heard of it) a compilation of 40 "belief-shaking remarks" by Nietzsche. The first one was:

"People who have given us their complete confidence believe that they have a right to ours. The inference is false, a gift confers no rights."

I found this latter part pretty interesting. As Matt had mentioned, when he gave his bike away he expected that the receiver take good care of it, use it well, enjoy it, tell him about his adventures on it, etc. But are these rights? I suppose not, but as we've talked about, it would certainly discourage more gift giving.

Thoughts?








(The whole list can be found at http://www.raptitude.com/2010/03/40-belief-shaking-remarks-from-a-ruthless-nonconformist/ )

7 comments:

  1. I agree with Nieche that one is not entitled to another's confidence simply because one confided in that person. However, the generalization that a gift confers no rights is not cohesive with Mauss' analysis. If we agree with Mauss that the reception of a gift obligates the receiver to reciprocate in some manner, then it seems reasonable to claim that the giver is entitled, at the very least, to that reciprocation.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree that my expectations for my friend's behavior do not amount to rights -- only desires, preferences, hopes, and somewhat reasonable expectations. Of course, if none of them are fulfilled, I may be less generous in the future, and this imposes a collective cost. In our largely commercial culture, rights come primarily with legal standing (contract, etc.).

    The question is whether the obligation to reciprocate a gift in Mauss's examples does indeed amount to a rights-claim on the part of the giver. It's not an easily enforced one, clearly, so it seems not to be a right in the fully legalistic sense above, but it may perhaps be a moral right in some sense (if there is such a thing apart from legality).

    Nietzsche disagrees, apparently, though in his characteristic oracular fashion he doesn't tell us why.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree that giving a gift does not give any special rights to the giver. It is not guaranteed, even if it is expected, to reciprocate the gift. I don't see that as a right, but more of a responsibility on the receiver's end to share something with the person who gave them the gift.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I am not sure that a right could be somehow separated from its legal implications. I was thinking back to Nick's post from last week in which Mauss gives the example of the giver being able (if he or she has not received a gift back) to take something from the person he or she gave a gift to by force. In this case it seems that the person does have a kind of right. So using that example if I take something by force from someone I gave a gift to, then I wouldn't be stealing? given that what I take is of equal or greater value?

    ReplyDelete
  5. Mauss shows us that for a gift to remain active and alive, reciprocation is necessary. But, this reciprocation need not be returned directly to the giver; but might very well find its way back to he initial giver during it’s cycle. I agree with everyone that a person who confides in another is not owed this trust or faith in return. But, if the gift of trust is genuine, I think the receiver might be moved to offer other persons a similar confidence. I agree with Nietzsche that "the inference is false”, but a gift might very possess moral rights. I also think that a moral right might exist separately from a legal right. (But I’ll need an example to make a claim for moral rights.)

    ReplyDelete
  6. A possible case for a moral right that exists separately from a legal right: It is not illegal to drink alcohol and smoke during pregnancy. Yet, drinking and smoking might have detrimental effects on a foetus. Should a developing foetus have a moral right inside the womb? This is a contentious issue; so for sake of argument let us assume that the foetus will be born and is in the third trimester. A foetus does not have legal rights (except not to be harmed after a certain point, I think). Should a foetus have a moral right: or, does a foetus have a moral right to develop free from the adverse effects of alcohol and smoking? I don’t want to get too far away from our topics, but I think this relates to some of the discussions about our “estates”, and guardianship. Might this qualify as a moral right that exists separately from a legal right?

    ReplyDelete
  7. Another quote by Nietzsche from the list that relates directly to Lewis Hyde’s “the Gift”.

    The essence of all beautiful art,
    all great art, is gratitude.

    ReplyDelete