Saturday, April 24, 2010

Final Paper Thesis

Hey all, I'm tossing around two different theses for my final paper. I suppose the former would be more interesting, and harder to prove. The former would also be in contention with my midterm thesis (humans cannot rightfully be the owners of animals), since if under certain circumstances humans can own humans, it seems to follow that under certain circumstances humans can own animals.

The first:

Humans, under certain circumstances, can rightfully be the owners of other humans. By “rightful,” I mean that certain humans can sometimes have a morally valid claim to call certain other humans as under their ownership (I hesistate to use the word “property” here. Perhaps we need another word in reference to the ownership of humans). This is not an endorsement of slavery or oppression. This is problematic because some humans, when given ownership or power over another human, would abuse this power, possibly leading to slavery and oppression.

The second:

Humans cannot rightfully be the owners of other humans. By “rightful,” I mean that humans do not have a morally valid claim to call other humans their property. By “owners,” I mean humans who have the right to possess, control, sell, and decide the fate of other humans. This is in contention with the view that children are owned by their parents, and supplemented by the view that humans cannot rightfully be the owners of animals.

Thoughts/questions/concerns?