People have been talking about owning land on Skeptiblog. Land, to me, seems like too basic an element of life to be something that can be owned. Perhaps that is because it is not as tangible as things that I normally think of owning--a book, clothes, a house, etc. How far down does one's owned land go, anyhow? All the way to the center of the earth? Just a thought.
Anyhow, this reminded me of Peter Barnes' Sky Trust. Here's a link if you've not heard of it: . Does something have to be tangible and outlined in order to be owned? Or, as Tania suggested, does it have to do with usage?
There was something that troubled me in Locke's chapter about property. He speaks of a man picking up acorns under an oak. Because the man has put his labor into appropriating the acorns, they belong to him. However, it makes no mention of that situation of someone else owns the tree. So if Brendon decided to be rebellious and take that picnic on private property, and took some acorns from underneath a tree, wouldn't that be stealing? Would the simple act of him being on the land be stealing?
Sunday, January 31, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I tend to think land is tangible. However, the definition of land is conceptually intangible and somewhat arbitrary. The definition of land becomes less arbitrary and more tangible when people become a variable of the definition i.e. the relationship between people and land is real.
ReplyDeleteLand is pretty solid stuff, and measurably finite -- one reason that perhaps the digestion model of property is not so applicable here. Some have argued that all land should be held in trust, and only leased to users who have explicit obligations to care for it in ways favorable to future inhabitants.
ReplyDeleteI do not think that Brendon's presence on someone else's property would constitute an act of stealing. The crime of trespassing is another matter, although I'm not sure that trespassing is a violation of the Lockean concept of property.
ReplyDeleteWe would need more information to determine whether Brendon taking the acorn was theft in the Lockean sense either. The intent of the property owner concerning the tree and its acorns is a factor in the scenario. If the owner planted the tree, then Brendon has no right to its acorns. I also think that it is imposssible to determine the intent of the owner without consulting him, so taking the acorns without his consent is stealing at worst or surreptitious at best.
It might be useful to distinguish here what Locke says from what he might have said, while remaining consistent with his theory. Locke has a conventional view of ownership, such that trespassing or taking acorns w/o permission would be a violation of it.
ReplyDeleteWe might imagine, however, a more fluid application of his principles, such that harmless trespass, or collecting unused acorns for personal use, would not violate the owner's property. We would argue for this by interpreting a bit more strongly Locke's insistence on the role of intention and productive use -- making them not just the basis of property, but criteria of its continuance.