In her post, Gloria asked: "Can one being exactly convey their feelings to another being?" I think that she is right in saying that this is not possible. Different factors can bring us closer to conveying exact meaning: our relationship with the person with whom we are communicating the feeling to; the amount of thought we put into the communication; the form in which we communicate; etc.
I think a good analogy to this is reading a descriptive paragraph about, say, a couple walking down a beach. The author can use as many vivid descriptions and adjectives as she wants to describe the waves, and the sand, and the trees, and the people, and yet I am quite sure that the exact mental image that the reader gets is different from every person who reads the paragraph. However, with art, the image is already painted by the artist, and therefore the exact way that the artist is feeling is transferred to the canvas. I think that the problem lies in the transfer of emotion from the canvas to the observer. There are so many different ways to interpret a piece of art that I think the original feeling often gets lost or skewed by the observer.
This makes me wonder--would feelings perhaps be best expressed through both art and words?
Sunday, October 4, 2009
Tolstoy
This week, we spoke about Tolstoy's view that "art is one of the most necessary means of communication, without which man cannot live." I am not sure that he has me convinced of this. We discussed the possibility that this could just be hyperbole, (Socrates didn't say "the unexamined life cannot be lived," but, "the unexamined life is not worth living"--perhaps "a life without art is not worth living" is what Tolstoy means here?) but for the sake of this post I will take Tolstoy's claim literally.
The reason that Tolstoy believes that humanity would cease to live is because it would do away with one of our primary forms of communication. Tolstoy believes that art is a language--the language with which we communicate feelings--whereas words are the language with which we communicate thoughts. Without the communication of feelings, we would degenerate as a species. I think it is clear that without some form of art we would certainly not be the same species that we are today, but I do not think that we would cease to exist altogether. Tolstoy also neglects the fact that emotions are not solely expressed through art--they can be expressed through words arguably as well.
This leads to my question--are feelings best expressed through words or art?
The reason that Tolstoy believes that humanity would cease to live is because it would do away with one of our primary forms of communication. Tolstoy believes that art is a language--the language with which we communicate feelings--whereas words are the language with which we communicate thoughts. Without the communication of feelings, we would degenerate as a species. I think it is clear that without some form of art we would certainly not be the same species that we are today, but I do not think that we would cease to exist altogether. Tolstoy also neglects the fact that emotions are not solely expressed through art--they can be expressed through words arguably as well.
This leads to my question--are feelings best expressed through words or art?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)