Sunday, October 11, 2009

Response to Fay Bartow

In her blog this week, Fay asked: is it necessary for one to understand the message of an artwork?

I used to think that the interpretation of art was subjective. If someone read a poem, they could rightly take out of it whatever they pleased. However, I was discussing this with a friend this summer, and he made me think otherwise...

My friend told me of an English class he once had, where a student believed that all that mattered was how the reader interpreted the story. My friend's teacher responded by asking if it would be correct, when he read To Kill A Mockingbird, to conclude that Tom Robinson deserved his punishment. After all, Robinson was tried by a jury of his peers, and was attempting to escape prison. Though he could support his reasoning, was it correct to conclude this?

It seems to me that this is very incorrect, as it is not at all what Harper Lee intended. So in response to Fay's question -- yes, I think it is extremely necessary to understand the message in a piece of art. In fact, I think the message and the interpretation and understanding of the message is one of the most crucial aspects of art.

That being said, I think that often times the message of a work of art gets lost. Does this mean that the artist is failing, or that the observer is failing?

Freud

Freud suggests that artists disguise the fantasies that are behind their works of art, which then allows observers to enjoy their own fantasies through the work without feeling ashamed. This seems to be a plausible theory, but I have one problem with it -- the role of interpretation.

Let's say an artist fantasizes about owning a fast car and a big house. She then creates an abstract painting (no obvious cars or houses depicted) that expresses her fantasy. An observer sees the painting, and then enjoys his fantasy of living on the beach. The message, or emotion, has gotten lost in translation. According to Tolstoy this means that the artist has failed, but Freud says nothing of this dilemma. Perhaps I am missing the point, and because all of this interpretation is happening subconsciously, it does not matter that the fantasy be accurately conveyed.

In class this week, we talked about catharsis in the art world. We discussed art as a "release valve," or a sort of substitute for humans' more animalistic drives. It seems as if all humans would need some form of catharsis in their lives. This makes me wonder: is art the only kind of catharsis? And if so, does this mean that all humans are artists?