Professor Johnson said that our last Q&A would be about what our own art theory is, now that we've finished the course. We never got around to doing that, so I thought it would be fitting to end my blog with.
I like the intentionality thesis. I like that it is inclusive. I, for whatever reason, think that art should be art, as long as the artist thinks it is art. I'm not so positive about the observer being able to label something as well as the artist, though.
I also like Danto's theory about having to know art history and theory before you can understand an object as a work of art. I no longer think it is inclusive and elitist, as I think Hume's perfect observer is. I suppose that these two theories are slightly opposed; one is completely inclusive and the other limits art to those who know something about it...
On the other hand, Weitz raises some good objections. Perhaps giving art a definition will limit it for future generations. Though, I suppose we could just include in the definition, "art, thus far..."
Then there's Clive Bell's aesthetic emotion and significant form. I think they're important, even though I think he was confused on how to articulate what they were.
I also think that what Professor Johnson said about creativity is an important factor, even though what exactly creativity is is still up for debate. Johnson & Piper's idea of having a fixed spatiotemporal location is also important.
I'm not sure how to decide which factor takes precedence over the other. Until further notice, Art(Shelby)=?
What has everyone else concluded?
Sunday, December 13, 2009
Piper

I thought this was pretty brilliant.
I'm disappointed to end on Piper, though, I suppose because I still cannot fully understand her. I'm also disappointed that this is the only woman we have read this semester. I suppose Piper wouldn't like me saying that (distinguishing her from the other philosopher's we've read, just because she's a woman), but I think it's important to read views from people of all different genders, backgrounds, countries, etc.
I asked about this in class, but for some reason it's still bothering me. Does Piper consider music to be performance art? Let me preface my question...
Performance art is the only art that is at least partially unique because it is unreproducible. It is unreproducible because it contains actual human beings as components. Other works of art are reproducible in that “we have the technological resources to replicate the color, shape, texture, and design of any object we can produce in the first place” (267).
Now, with music, don’t we have the technology to duplicate it? Not just duplicating CDs as Professor Johnson suggested...but don't we have computer technology that can replicate the sounds that are made by instruments? I suppose this would still require human interaction...a human would be needed to press the buttons (say, on an electric keyboard that is making Violin sounds). What if we had a computer with a program written to eliminate the human interaction? Perhaps I'm getting a bit too Sci-Fi.
I think music is different from other types of performance art, like dances and plays. I don't think that a play could be performed the exact same way twice, but I think I song could. Is it the medium of the instrument that makes it reproducible? If so, what of singing? What do you think, is music performance art in the same way that plays and dances are?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)