Thought I'd share my SLAP with you all. Let me know what you think.
S: Is a greater total or average happiness of a society more important than the lowest common denominator of unhappiness of a society?
L: Waldron writes: “There is no right-based argument to be found which provides an adequate justification for a society in which some people have lots of property and many have next to none” (Waldron 5). He later writes: “Many of the most familiar arguments in favour of private property and against socialism are utilitarian arguments. They purport to show that the total or average happiness of society will be greater, or that the general welfare (under some other utilitarian conception) will be better served, if [a system of private property is used]” (Waldron 6).
A: It seems as though with the system of private property, yes, the total or average happiness of a society could be greater than with socialism, but it would be more polarized (the happy people would be very happy, and the unhappy people would be very unhappy). I think perhaps it would be more important to raise the lowest common denominator of unhappy people (this does not mean bringing everyone down to their level!) than to upkeep a high average happiness.
P: Would socialism ensure a less polarized level of happiness than a system of private property?
Monday, April 26, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
According to Bentham, you will recall, utilitarianism itself, properly understood, would yield a comparable result. I think the argument looks like this:
ReplyDelete1) In an unequal society, there are almost always more poor than rich (observation)
2) A utilitarian calculation counts the net pleasure/pain of each person/sentient being equally (stipulation of the theory)
3) The pain/lack of pleasure of widespread poverty is almost certain to overwhelm the pleasure of the wealthy few in the total net calculation (1, 2)
4) Therefore, utilitarianism requires a high degree of equality.
If the above is a fair reconstruction of Bentham's reasoning, then those defenders of the economic status quo who style themselves utilitarians may be doing so disingenuously, or at least fallaciously.
ReplyDeleteOn the other hand, there is something odd about the utilitarian argument as a moral argument, strictly speaking. Should we oppose poverty because a contingent and hypothetical abstraction (greatest good of greatest number) happens to entail equality, or rather because, as our empathic capacity shows, everyone has a right to a decent life, whether utility says so or not?