Sunday, September 27, 2009

Response to Natasha Robinson

In her blog this week, Natasha asked: "is it not the intent of art to connect observers with the artwork and object represented?" We have spoken a lot in class about defining art, but have not quite delved into the subject of the intention of art. I think that what Natasha is asking is just one of many possible intentions that a work of art could have.

I do not think that the intent of art is to connect observers with the artwork and represented object, so much as it is to connect observers to the feeling that the art produces. If we look at Tolstoy (am I getting ahead of myself here?), he believes that art is a form of communication, almost a language, that conveys a past feeling of the artist to the observer. I do not agree with Tolstoy that beauty and pleasure has no significance in the art world, but I do agree that feeling, both of the artist and the observer, is a major component of art's intent.

The Sincerest Form of Flattery

We have all heard Colton's famous saying, "imitation is the sincerest form of flattery." Though I think this is usually used ironically, I wonder what Plato would think about this saying. I suppose that it does not matter that the Forms are flattered, but perhaps this says something about the nature of art. If art is attempting to sincerely imitate the Forms and truly tap into them, I do not see how that can be a bad thing.

Plato said that "music is the highest philosophy" because it is the most tapped into the Forms and does not imitate anything. If that is the case, is it the mere imitation of a Form or object that Plato has a problem with? I wonder what Plato would think of the white canvas used in our book's introduction, or a Jackson Pollack painting.

If Plato did not want art in his Republic because art is an imitation of an imitation, I think it would follow that Plato would not want the imitation, the object, either. It seems like Plato makes no objection to having beds in his Republic. I suppose this is simply because living in a world without objects would be impractical.

My unrelated question: In class on Wednesday, we talked about how humans are inclined to look for representation in things (clouds, a Pollack painting, etc.), even when there is no intended representation. Why would an artist want not to represent something, and do you think an artist would intentionally not represent something, knowing/hoping that the observers would make their own representations?