This week, Michelle asked, "All theory aside, what is art to you?"
I can't believe I haven't asked myself this question since this class began. I guess I've been too caught up in all of the different views to sit down and consider my own.
In middle school, I went to a tiny arts school called the Museum Partnership School. The building was run down, the paint was falling off the ceiling onto our books--scratch that, we didn't have money for books--and there were about 40 kids in my grade level. Since we didn't have much money, (I learned then that the state cares more about MCAS scores than our "alternative" methods of learning) our teachers came up with some pretty unorthodox teaching methods. I haven't really actively learned anything about art since my two years there, before this class.
The question, "What is art?" was raised pretty much daily at MPS. I think my definition of art then and my definition of art now are the same, albeit terribly clichéd...
I think that art is any form of expression. We talked about catharsis in class, and I think that all forms of catharsis are art. This is a pretty inclusive definition, but I think that it is in the nature of art to be inclusive. Why do we have to be art snobs, anyway? If someone wants to paint a barely visible diagonal line on a white canvas and call it art, it's not going to hurt anyone to agree that it is art. I'm suppose I am a full supporter of the intentionality thesis.
An unrelated question:
Clive Bell writes that "A good critic may be able to make me see in a picture that had left me cold things that I had overlooked, till at last, receiving the emotion, I recognise it as a work of art. ...But it is useless for a critic to tell me that something is a work of art; he must make me feel it for myself" (119). Do you agree with this?
Sunday, October 18, 2009
Clive Bell
Professor Johnson's latest blog post has to do with the circularity of significant form and aesthetic emotion. Since we cannot come up with a good definition for significant form without being circular, Professor Johnson proposes that we leave significant form undefined. This, however, would reduce Bell's thesis to two "apparently insignificant claims:
*All and only those objects with some unknown property are art.
Or
*All and only those objects that evoke some unknown aesthetic emotional reaction are art."
I do not understand how Bell could fail to provide adequate definitions for the two crucial components of his thesis. He must have noticed their circularity, though he does not mention it (at least not in our excerpt).
Perhaps Bell's vague, "unknown" thesis is telling of his formalist view. The question frequently came up in class this week, "Then what is art to Bell?" If you take away the details, the representation, and the form from art...what are you left with? A blank canvas? That canvas still has form, because it's still a three dimensional object with lines. It still represents blankness, or fog, or purity. So we take the canvas away and are left with...nothing? I'm not sure that Clive Bell knows what we are left with. Perhaps this is why he gives us, as Professor Johnson writes, "unknown aesthetic emotional reactions" and "unknown properties."
I've wrapped my mind around Clive Bell's art views in theory, but I cannot think of how to put them to use. I had a similar problem with Plato. I suppose I just do not understand what is so bad about representation.
Question:
We did not get around to suggesting formulas for Clive Bell's view of art in class. Does anyone have a try?
*All and only those objects with some unknown property are art.
Or
*All and only those objects that evoke some unknown aesthetic emotional reaction are art."
I do not understand how Bell could fail to provide adequate definitions for the two crucial components of his thesis. He must have noticed their circularity, though he does not mention it (at least not in our excerpt).
Perhaps Bell's vague, "unknown" thesis is telling of his formalist view. The question frequently came up in class this week, "Then what is art to Bell?" If you take away the details, the representation, and the form from art...what are you left with? A blank canvas? That canvas still has form, because it's still a three dimensional object with lines. It still represents blankness, or fog, or purity. So we take the canvas away and are left with...nothing? I'm not sure that Clive Bell knows what we are left with. Perhaps this is why he gives us, as Professor Johnson writes, "unknown aesthetic emotional reactions" and "unknown properties."
I've wrapped my mind around Clive Bell's art views in theory, but I cannot think of how to put them to use. I had a similar problem with Plato. I suppose I just do not understand what is so bad about representation.
Question:
We did not get around to suggesting formulas for Clive Bell's view of art in class. Does anyone have a try?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)