After our Owning and Belonging class on Monday, I went home and read out of "The Earth Knows My Name" by Patricia Klindienst. It's a collection of tales about "food, culture, and sustainability in the gardens of ethnic Americans." I'm reading the book for my Director's Book Course. With property on my mind, I had an interesting perspective on the book (I love when ideas from two classes merge together!).
While describing the Gullah people of South Carolina, she notes that the man she's interviewing, Ralph, "never uses the word property or mine in speaking of [his land]." He says that the Gullah "feel that we are part of the land." Ralph also expresses his distaste for gated communities and fences around property, saying, "everybody here was raised to feel free to walk anywhere," and, "Here, you respect a person's land."
I think that perhaps this is what we need to try to get back to. We need a basic respect for people and to see land as more than a commodity. I think as a culture we have lost touch with the land, and certainly don't "feel that we are a part of the land" as the Gullah do. We need to get back to our literal and figurative roots in the land.
Sunday, February 14, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Thanks for bringing that in. I love it when I don't have to make all the connections myself!
ReplyDeleteThe contrast of course is not between property and no property, but between property enforced by law, fences, and threats, on the one hand, and property honored as a matter of respect for the people who garden it on the other hand. We can hear echoes of Locke here, and this idea of estate as an extension of one's personhood will be important to bear in mind, I think.
We are very much a part of the land; and it's baffling to see how some people behave in a hostile manner regarding things we are dependent upon. And, I agree, that on a whole we need a "basic respect", this is a great beginning. Gated communities remind me of films where the gangster snitch is locked-up--not for the communities protection, but for his/her own. These self-induced prisons operate on the notion that safety is obtainable through the use of bars, gates, fences, guards, alarms, etc. The result is a false sense of security and sheer aniexty, paranoia, and apprehension in the 'real' world. So, perhaps it makes more sense that respect, empathy, and, reason replace the artificiality of fences and gates.
ReplyDeleteOn a similar note, I don't understand the concept of golf courses. It's not so much the game I'm bothered by as it's the way it's advertised like some private retreat for only the wealthy people. There's a golf "community" not far from where I live, which happens to be located in a very poor neighborhood. I am offended it's there because it can very easily be transformed into a public park, which would benefit everyone in the area, in particular the kids, who have it rough already living in such a dump of a city. To me, this is a perfect visual representation of the "haves" and "have nots" where the grass is literally greener on the other side.
ReplyDeleteI just feel it's unfair to quarter off a big piece of land and deny access to the people who have every right to own some part of it as well.
I have family that lives on a ranch in the middle of nowhere Arizona, and the first time I went out to visit them I was amazed to see that everyone's property was fenced in. Not just the ranches--I'm talking trailer homes in the middle of the desert with a fence around the land and a gate in the driveway. It looked, as Keane said, like they were isolating themselves. My uncle said the fences were so other people couldn't steal things. They seemed to be very wary of intruders; much more so than people here. Yes, we have gated communities here and the occasional paranoid rich person with a gate, but for the most part it's strange to see homes with fences around them. I'm not sure if the residents of rural AZ were afraid of their neighbors or stray deviants wandering the desert, but it seems as though their fences were a monument to their lack of trust in mankind.
ReplyDeleteI've seen that in Arizona and other parts of the southwest, and I always assumed they were just trying to keep out roving livestock, quite a bit of which wanders around open land in those parts.
ReplyDeleteGood point. Like those weird cattle guard grates that go across the road. Maybe my uncle's just paranoid.
ReplyDeleteI agree with the Gullah people's state of mind fully, but the current state of consciousness (for America) has been conditioned by an industrial form of society. At this point, it seems like the Gullah's conceptions of property are utopian. Also, America is very populated in most regions and you can't trust that many people altogether. There's always going to be someone who unfairly takes from another,or someone who makes more money, or someone who thinks everything belongs to them. These factors may be the result of being conditioned in a competitive economic context.
ReplyDeleteI hope we can return to a state of mind where everyone feels one with the earth and each other.
I agree, Matt, that in some overpopulated places the Gullah's system may not work as well. I can't help but think that our distrust of people is self-perpetuating, though--perhaps by showing that we have more faith in humankind, people would act more responsibly.
ReplyDelete