I was thinking about the difference between possessing something and owning something today. Just for clarification: (from dictionary.com) Possession: Law. actual holding or occupancy, either with or without rights of ownership. Ownership: 1. the state or fact of being an owner. 2.legal right of possession; proprietorship.
So clearly just because we possess something does not mean we own it. However, we've all heard the saying "possession is 9 points of the law." Ownership is a mental construct, while possession is something physical.
This makes me wonder about the origin of ownership. I wonder when earlier humans made the distinction between ownership and possession? It seems as though language is required to have ownership rather than possession, since ownership requires more than one person. Do animals distinguish between the two?
Sunday, February 7, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I think "ownership" is how we maintain order. You can see this in pack animals, like dogs, who organize their hierarchy based on a system of who "owns" the pack. True pack leaders dominate over the group but they know their power is not absolute. Any one of the younger, stronger members can take over the Alpha Male or Female. It's a system that works in order to ensure the survival of the community.
ReplyDeleteHowever, with humans, I think it's more than just about survival. We were talking in class the other day about the difference between "should" and "ought", and I think the same rationale applies here: humans should own property but why ought they? And I think language, as you noted, may be a key element in answering that question because our system of language is so complex and it is truly unique among all the creatures of the world that it's hard to ignore that it might have something to do with why we are so fixated on defining our property borders.
I thought of something interesting in regards to animals: what about, say, birds that collect shiny man-made trinkets, and attack people that try to take them back? Or dogs that have a favorite toy, and refuse to give it up or share it? Are these examples of animals having a notion of ownership and possession similar to how we think of the concept?
ReplyDeleteYou could also consider territorial animals to have some idea of "ownership" of the land they mark as their territory.
Spot on, I think. Our intuitions about such things are surely rooted in the very distant evolutionary past -- far deeper than our own species. This may be one reason Locke thinks that property relationships are more fundamental than legal or political ones, arising in the state of nature.
ReplyDeleteI think an element of outside consensus is also what helps make the appropriate distinction between the two concepts--with all creatures of intelligent thought, a sort of 'exterior acknowledgment' is typically what indicates ownership. Put more simply, my intuition tells me that many of us come to believe we own something if others recognize and accept that we do.
ReplyDelete