Sunday, November 15, 2009

Response to Tasha

Tasha responded to my post, and then asked, "Art may truly need an observer, but does the observer have to be aware that they are filling that role? Could non-sentient observers be viable in this theoretical situation? How would that work?"

I have wondered about sentient life (other than humans) being observers of art, but I have not yet thought about non-sentient life in this role. I think that the purpose of the observer is to reflect upon the art for being art...that is where the observer's purpose comes from. I do not think that non-sentient beings could fulfill the role of an observer because if they cannot reflect upon themselves, then I doubt they could reflect upon a piece of art. Perhaps as far as they would go would be to notice the piece of art as a part of their environment (e.g. they would hear music playing, but recognize it as merely sounds, not art). I think that perhaps art does need an observer, that is, someone to appreciate, reflect and place value upon it. Without an observer, art is...well, meaningless color on a board.

So, taking this a step closer, could sentient life (not humans) play the role of observer for a work of art? What if, in the Last Man Experiment, only humans had died off, and other sentient life still existed? Could non-humans play the role of observers, thus making art, art?

Goodman

Goodman's claim that "a stone is normally no work of art while in the driveway, but may be so when on display in an art museum" (202) does not sit well with me. A stone is a stone is a stone, in both environments. I might actually argue that the stone is more aesthetic in a driveway, or on a mountainside, as that is it's natural environment.

Goodman's reasoning is that a stone in a driveway is found art, which doesn't symbolize anything, but a stone in a museum exemplifies its properties of shape, color, size, etc. However--does this rock not have the same internal properties whether it is lying on the ground or on a pedestal in a museum?

This makes me think about a few things I've been learning about value in my Environmental Ethics class.

Firstly:
We talked about a rock having "primary qualities" -- an inherent, determinate length, height, mass, etc...the same as Goodman's driveway stone. We asked if the fact that this rock has these qualities demand anything of us morally. Similarly--does the fact that this rock has these qualities demand anything from us aesthetically?

Also:
It seems as if, according to Goodman (and many other theories we have read), art needs an observer. I don't think that we have yet heard a theory which claims art to be intrinsically valuable. In Environmental Ethics, we questioned if the environment was inherently valuable, or simply instrumentally valuable to humans. We read a thought experiment, dubbed the "last man experiment" which seems to show that many people find the environment intrinsically valuable...I thought I might apply this experiment to art (I paraphrase Jamieson in his book, Ethics and the Environment, p. 74):

Suppose that Fred is the last sentient creature on the plant and he knows that, for whatever reason, sentient life will never again appear on this planet. Just before exiting the scene, Fred blows up every museum on the planet and destroys every piece of artwork that ever existed. What Fred destroys is of great beauty, but he defends his action by saying that it doesn't matter, since it will never again be appreciated or valued by anyone.

My question to you, again paraphrased from Jamieson:
Do we accept Fred's justification, or was his act wrong?