Sunday, December 6, 2009

Dickie's response to Weitz

Last Wednesday, as Professor Johnson blogged, Tom Wartenberg suggested that Danto responds to Weitz' views when he discusses Warhol's Brillo box. But the conversation never mentioned Dickie's response to Weitz. Although Dickie never directly responds to Weitz in that he never says Weitz' name, Dickie does respond to some of Weitz' ideas.

Dickie writes that "In the mid-1950's, several philosophers, inspired by Wittgenstein's talk about concepts, began arguing that there are no necessary and sufficient conditions for art." Dickie disagrees, and then claims to be able to show the N&S conditions.

More interestingly, though, is Dickie's response to Weitz' idea that any definition of art would be too restrictive and possibly restrain future art. Dickie writes that "some social institutions are formal and some are informal. The artworld could become formalized, and perhaps has been to some extent in certain political contexts, but most people who are interested in art would probably consider this a bad thing. Such formality would threaten the freshness and exuberance of art" (223). Dickie then abruptly changes the subject to the personnel of the art world.

I think that this is a bit of a cop-out of a response. Dickie recognizes the problem, but does not address howa definition of art will not do what Weitz proposes it will do.

Dickie earlier writes that “plays are written to have a place in the theater system and they exist as plays, that is, as art, within that syystem” (221). This means that plays are intended to be art. What, then, of the stone from the driveway that is put on display? The stone was not created with the intention of eventually becoming art.

Response to Stephanie

Thanks, Stephanie, for looking that up. I forgot to do it myself. I'm surprised that the Communist Party didn't have a candidate. Also, perhaps McCain should have thought, "Hmm, the KKK endorses me. Perhaps something is wrong here..." Oh well.

I think that Stephanie's suggestion is right that the reason people who have very slim chances of being nominated president start a campaign is to spread their opinions and hope to get a few followers. I'm not sure how well it works, as I'm sure that the majority of U.S. citizens have never heard most of these candidate's names before. I doubt that they go into their campaign expecting to have a shot at presidency.

I don't think that Dickie's "candidacy" for art is quite as exclusive as running for President, however. I think the word candidacy makes it seem like the chances of becoming actual art are slim. Art seems more inclusive than that. Perhaps Dickie should have chosen another word.

I was certainly put off the first time I read Dickie's "candidacy" line. It seemed a little hazy, but it wasn't until we talked about Dickie in class that I realized that this isn't the only place Dickie was trying to dupe his reader. This made me read Dickie with an even more critical, skeptical eye. During my brief relationship with Philosophy here at MCLA, one of the things I've learned is to be straightforward--to say what I mean, and exactly what I mean, and shut up. Dickie appears to be breaking this cardinal rule.

What does everyone else think about Dickie's "candidacy" premise?