When I first read Danto, I thought that his theory that one needs to know the theories and history of art in order to understand an object as a work of art was a bit elitist. I thought that art should be something that is accessible to everybody; not just those who are schooled in the subject. However, I now think that this is a pretty necessary condition of establishing something as a work of art.
I don't think that this means one cannot have an opinion or judgment about an object (be it art or not) but rather that when it comes to the actual classification, to leave it up to those who know best. We let those who know science do science, those who know math do math, but for some reason when it comes to the art we are a bit more touchy. A lot of people feel entitled to be in some part involved with art, and I think a lot of people would take offense if told they weren't qualified to call something art. Perhaps science and math are just more concrete than art is.
I think that Danto's observer's are different from Hume's ideal observers because they are more accessible. I still doubt whether there is any such person that would meet Hume's criteria for art observer. The questions still stand, however--how much history and theory does one need to know in order to be qualified? Is it on a continuum, like, "you are x amount qualified to call something art." Is there one person out there who is the most qualified, and (s)he needs to be doing all of the classification for the artworld?
What do you think--does Danto's theory that one needs to know art history and theory in order to understand an object as art seem elitist to you? Are you alright with knowing that you are not qualified to understand art?
Saturday, November 28, 2009
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)