De gustibus non est disputandum -- There is no disputing about taste.
I agree with Michelle in that if you have a certain view about artwork, you should be allowed to hold that view without being forced to think otherwise. I do not think that this applies, however, to PETA's commercial.
Say there was a painting at MoCA that you did not like. That is your taste. Now, if the museum curator came up to you and told you the back story to the painting, and pointed out subtleties in the painting that you had not noticed, perhaps your taste would change. As Professor Johnson said, if you read a book about the Mona Lisa, you're more apt to like and/or appreciate it.
I think that this was all PETA was going for here--to educate people about their cause, in order to let them make their own decision about what they think. Yes, it has shock value, and yes, it is explicit, and these aren't necessarily good qualities of the commercial (I support what PETA stands for, but usually not the way they go about things), but perhaps they are needed to get people's attention. The truth is that nothing in the commercial is exaggerated, and everything the girl says is a fact that most people try to ignore. The more you know about a subject, the better an educated decision you can make about it...whether it's art, or meat, politics, etc. But I would hardly say that this commercial is forcing a view. Many of my non-vegetarian friends who watched this commercial laughed at it and said that they still couldn't wait for their Thanksgiving turkey. I think the hope is that a few people will take the message seriously, perhaps further their education on the subject, and then make an educated decision.
I'm sorry to get off topic of art, but I think it's an important discussion. What are other peoples' thoughts on the commercial?
Sunday, November 29, 2009
Dickie
When Dickie is talking about how the status of candidate for appreciation is conferred, he writes that "a number of persons are required to make up the social institution of the artworld, but only one person is required to act on behalf of the artworld and to confer the status of candidate for appreciation. In fact, many works of art are seen only by one person--the one who creates them--but they are still art." (224)
This seems quite inclusive. In fact, I don't see much of a difference between this theory and the Intentionality Thesis. If a 5 year old "sees himself as a member of the artworld" (and is therefore a member), creates a finger painting, and labels it art, then according to what Dickie has just said, this is art. Why, then, go through all of this trouble when his theory simply boils down to IT?
In all of Dickie's other examples of conferring status, the one who confers has the authority to do so (e.g. A king's conferring of knighthood; a minister's pronouncing a couple man and wife. A peasant would not have the authority to knight someone, and any given civilian off the street could not legally marry two people.). What gives any given person the authority to label art as art? Why does Dickie not mention Danto's theory about needing to know the history and theories of art?
This seems quite inclusive. In fact, I don't see much of a difference between this theory and the Intentionality Thesis. If a 5 year old "sees himself as a member of the artworld" (and is therefore a member), creates a finger painting, and labels it art, then according to what Dickie has just said, this is art. Why, then, go through all of this trouble when his theory simply boils down to IT?
In all of Dickie's other examples of conferring status, the one who confers has the authority to do so (e.g. A king's conferring of knighthood; a minister's pronouncing a couple man and wife. A peasant would not have the authority to knight someone, and any given civilian off the street could not legally marry two people.). What gives any given person the authority to label art as art? Why does Dickie not mention Danto's theory about needing to know the history and theories of art?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
