We didn't get a chance to talk about my SLAP last week, and I'm curious as to what everyone else thinks about it. I suppose I'll just recreate it here:
S: What would happen when subsistence and security contradict?
L: "It will sometimes happen that a measure suggested by one of these principles will be condemned by another...When this contradiction exists between two of these ends, it is necessary to find some means of deciding the pre-eminence...At the first glance we see subsistence and security arising together to the same level; abundance and equality are manifestly of inferior importance. In face, without security, equality could not last a day; without subsistence, abundance could not exist at all. The two first objects are life itself; the two latter, the ornaments of life." (Chapter II, pp. 42-43)
A: Bentham says that "In legislation, the most important object is security" (43), but does not identify which is more important for happiness. He makes it clear that subsistence and security are more foundational than security and eqaulity, but if a situation arose in which one had to benefit and one had to suffer, he does not specify what is right in that case.
P: Which takes precedence for Bentham: subsistence or security?
Saturday, March 6, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I would argue security, as he refers to security and equality as "life itself" while he calls subsistence and abundance "the ornaments of life."
ReplyDeleteBentham considers security “the pre-eminent object”. Provide security for the laborer and the fruits of his/her labor and you indirectly provide for subsistence. But this is with the establishment of laws. Bentham speaks of the “physical sanction being sufficient” and regards “natural motives” as having irresistible power. Is Bentham saying that security is the one thing we do not possess, or is not guaranteed, in a state of nature? “Which takes precedence for Bentham: subsistence or security?” In a state of law, Bentham seems to be making a strong case for security. I think, also, that in a state of nature security might take precedence—or is equal to subsistence. It seems that in order to provide for our selves in nature, we might need “liberty” to ‘dispose” of our property or persons –(Locke) in an effectual manner to secure subsistence. In this sense, and in this “usage”, personal property both secures and is subsistence for a particular individual. The possibility of subsistence without some degree of security is questionable—And laws provide additional security for laborers and the fruits of their labor.
ReplyDeleteNick, I think he's referring to subsistence and security as "life itself," and equality and abundance as "the ornaments of life," hence my problem in distinguishing which is most important.
ReplyDeleteYeah I misread it. I would have to agree with Keane and say that Bentham seems to lean towards "security," as security could be seen as necessary for true subsistence.
ReplyDeleteGoing beyond the question, I agree with Keane's argument and with Bentham's that security precedes subsistence, but I'm curious as to the application of this viewpoint. If it is assumed that security in a state of law is critical for the people's subsistence, is it assumed also that security is critical for the people's maintenance? In other words, does security also refer to the protection of people from over-indulgence? (with apologies for answering your question with another question!)
ReplyDeleteGood question. Here's a related one: does the primacy of security in Bentham entail, for example, an obligation on the part of the law to protect citizens from the depredations of the market (business cycles, churn, speculative bubbles) and also unemployment, home foreclosure, etc.?
ReplyDeleteIf so, perhaps the spirit of utilitarianism and free-market boosterism could be humanized after all.
I agree with Keane in his analysis of Bentham, in the sense that Bentham does seem to place security as the primary legislative objective over the others.
ReplyDeleteHaving said that, I think that Bentham has a misapplied sense of priority. His argument is that by providing security for individuals and their property, security provides the opportunity for individuals to provide subsistence for themselves. He fails to recognize, however, that without subsistence people would not have the ability to do anything but seek subsistence. Furthermore, without subistence, which we recognize as the "bare essentials", there is nothing to protect. I think, therefore, that they are corequisites for society.
Bentham believes that laws can do nothing but provide motives for men to provide for themselves, and even that is a waste, arguing that the natural incentives for subsistence are sufficient in themselves. What he does not recognize is that laws can also provide opportunity for subsistence within a society, besides simply protecting the property that people already have. I believe that under such principles, it is the resopnsibility of the government to provide the opportunity for people to acquire their own subsistence, i.e. when there is high unemployment it shuld be the obligation of the government to provide work for unemployed citizens.