
Weitz writes that "some games resemble others in some respects--that is all. What we find are no necessary and sufficient properties, only a 'complicated network of similarities and crisscrossing,' such that we say of games that they form a family with family resemblances and no common trait" (190).
This had me thinking--what's so wrong about "strands of similarities?"
I'm not sure if this example will hold water with anyone, but the first thing that came to mind was the computer game, "The Logical Journey of the Zoombinis." There was one part of the game where you had to sit Zoombinis (those cute little things in above picture) in seats along the perimeter of a boat. This has a point, I promise. You could only sit two Zoombinis next to each other if they had at least one similar trait (ponytail, purple nose, sunglasses, etc.) So, when you were finished, there were 20 or so Zoombinis in a circle, and every Zoombini had a trait similar to the Zoombini on the left and right of him.
Now, it was also possible that any two random Zoombinis in your group (not sitting next to each other, of course) had no similar traits. You could have a girl with a ponytail, sunglasses, a red nose, and a spring, and a boy with spikey hair, one eye, an orange nose, and rollerblades--nothing similar, other than being Zoombinis. Now, let's throw a third Zoombini in--he has one little tuft of hair, an orange nose, tired eyes, and a spring. Now these three Zoombinis all share "strands of similarities." Stick with me here.
Let's apply this to games. This complicates matters because traits of a game are more complex than just color and hairstyle. Let's take Chess and the hand game Miss Mary Mack. Let's say that they have no similar traits, other than being games. Then, add Monopoly to the mix...and say that Monopoly and Chess share some similarities, and Miss Mary Mack and Monopoly share some similarities. If we somehow know that Miss Mary Mack and Chess are games, but don't know that Monopoly is a game, then we could infer that because Monopoly shares characteristics with other games, it too is a game.
This seems to be what Weitz means when he says, "If one asks what a game is, we pick out sample games, describe these, and add, 'This and similar things are called games'." As we said in class, we would need to clarify what "similar things" are. It's easy enough to say that traditional things like Chess and Monopoly are games, but what about more obscure things like mind games, or animals seemingly playing games? Where do you draw the line?
No comments:
Post a Comment