This week, William asked: "Since animals and humans are related on a similar basis, who proclaims that animals cannot produce works of art such as humans do?" I think that what William is really asking here is not who thinks this way, but how those who do justify their thinking.
I am interested in this question because I am learning about similar problems in my Environmental Ethics course. I think the main problem here is that people often forget that humans are animals too. Dale Jamieson, the author of my Environmental Ethics text, writes that "we are not only rational agents but also animals, and in virtue of this we have an animal nature" (Ethics and the Environment 98). By animal nature, Jamieson means things like human love for food and drink, sex, curiosity, etc. He goes on to say that "since we value the goods that flow from our animal nature, we are committed to valuing these goods when they are instatiated in other creatures as well...if we value our own appreciation of art, then we are also committed to valuing a dog's appreciation of (what are to him) interesting smells, and a monkey's valuing of swinging from trees" (99).
I think that Jamieson misses something here...we are also committed to valuing an animal's appreciation of art. I think that, as Professor Johnson proposed in class, the ability to desire and appreciate aesthetically pleasing things appears at the same time that animals have a sense of self.
What does everyone else think about this? Another thought--how does the intentionality thesis apply to animals?
Sunday, October 25, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I just added a qualification to my most recent post on "Art and Nature" after reading this. Thanks!
ReplyDelete