Wartenberg's introduction to Dewey states that "an important feature of [Dewey's definition of art] is that it unites various aspects of art often treated as distinct. For example, both artist and audience play equally important roles in this definition" (Wartenberg 137). I did not find this idea while reading Dewey's work. I thought that Dewey's roles for the observer/audience were somewhat vague or even contradictory. When I asked about this in class, Professor Johnson clarified it a bit for me (it's not contradictory, it's just on a continuum...), but I am still a little confused.
The formula for the Intentionality Thesis that we have been working with is
A= Ia or o
where I=intention, A=artist and O=observer. On pages 140 and 143, Dewey seems to remove the "O" from this formula. Thus, the role of the observer is downplayed, and art is only art when the artist intends it to be so. However, on page 145, Dewey says that "to be truly artistic, a work must also be esthetic--that is, framed for enjoyed receptive perception." This seems to mean that a work of art needs an observer to appreciate it. This is why I am confused.
Can anyone help me out here? What is your take on the role of the observer/audience in Dewey's theory of art?
Sunday, October 25, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment