Saturday, April 24, 2010

Final Paper Thesis

Hey all, I'm tossing around two different theses for my final paper. I suppose the former would be more interesting, and harder to prove. The former would also be in contention with my midterm thesis (humans cannot rightfully be the owners of animals), since if under certain circumstances humans can own humans, it seems to follow that under certain circumstances humans can own animals.

The first:

Humans, under certain circumstances, can rightfully be the owners of other humans. By “rightful,” I mean that certain humans can sometimes have a morally valid claim to call certain other humans as under their ownership (I hesistate to use the word “property” here. Perhaps we need another word in reference to the ownership of humans). This is not an endorsement of slavery or oppression. This is problematic because some humans, when given ownership or power over another human, would abuse this power, possibly leading to slavery and oppression.

The second:

Humans cannot rightfully be the owners of other humans. By “rightful,” I mean that humans do not have a morally valid claim to call other humans their property. By “owners,” I mean humans who have the right to possess, control, sell, and decide the fate of other humans. This is in contention with the view that children are owned by their parents, and supplemented by the view that humans cannot rightfully be the owners of animals.

Thoughts/questions/concerns?

2 comments:

  1. I’m intrigued by your first claim; and I wonder what “certain circumstances” might qualify for ownership of another human being-as opposed to being under, or in the care of, another person(s) guardianship. I think your second claim is sound; and, in America most reasonable people might agree. Also,I think most of us consider parents to be the guardians of children. At any rate, parents do not have an absolute right to “possess, control, sell, or decide the fate” of their children. But, other parts of the world still consider children property and kids are routinely sold into work and slave trades.

    Your first claim is more contentious in my view, and I am curious as to what benefits, if any, you think might be obtained through the “ownership” of people. This is not going to be a popular claim-and as I see it there is no justification for the ownership of another human being-but it might be interesting to parallel this with your claim about the ownership of animals to determine if our social behaviors are consistent or hypocritical concerning the ownership of sentient beings.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Consider two key Lockean presuppositions about property:
    1)that it is usufructory and thus not absolute, but only held and used in trust for others in the future,
    2)that the sort of property he calls estate flows from and thus is conceptually dependent on one's life itself, and the exercise of one's liberty in the expression of that life (what Hegel calls will).

    From these it follows both that ownership is at least as much about concrete responsibilities as it is about the right to dispose of your property as you please (this is part of what Locke means by 'within reason'), and that the core notion of property refers to something -- yourself -- where your liberty to do as you please is rather tightly constrained (see Erica's essay on self-ownership and suicide).

    Suppose we take the above as a hypothetical definition of property, and explore its implications and credibility in application. Among those implications will be that the ownership of one's children is neither absurd nor offensive, properly understood in terms of the definition. Another is that our treatment of inanimate objects as though we could consume and destroy them at will is foolish.

    It would be interesting to see the first of your theses worked out through some such reasoning as this, then challenged with the intuitions of the second.

    ReplyDelete