Saturday, November 14, 2009

Response to Alyson Carey

This week, Alyson asked, "Is there a set standard for taste?"

Hume writes that "it is natural for us to seep a Standard of Taste; a rule, by which the various sentiments of men may be reconciled; at least, a decision, afforded, conforming one sentiment, and condemning another" (42).

What I've read of my book review book (Taste: The Secret Meaning of Things, by Stephen Bayley) so far suggests a few things about the standard of taste. Firstly, we are all influenced by the taste of our times. Norman Bel Geddes suggests that if Keats had been writing during the 1940s, his famous poem would have written about an automobile or plane, rather than the Grecian Urn. Bayley claims that money and taste are inseparable, as are class and taste. Finally, according the Bayley, "the one certain thing about taste is that it changes."

My answer to this question is that no, there is not a set standard for taste. I agree with the statement Hume alludes to and disagrees with -- that there is no disputing about taste. Yes, tastes do change and rely on multiple factors such as education, class, status, wealth, and country of origin...but to set a standard for taste, in my opinion, would be impossible and pointless.

No comments:

Post a Comment